ISO 27001 or BSI Grundschutz++? Both standards result in an information security management system—but with very different approaches. In this video, we compare their similarities and differences and show you which questions to ask to decide which approach is right for your company.
From the BSI Grundschutz++ series · approx. 8 minutes
You are currently viewing a placeholder content from Default. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationISO 27001 and BSI Grundschutz++ share the same goal: IT security in practice that works in everyday life—not just a certificate on the wall. Both are management systems centered on a continuous improvement process, leadership accountability, and risk management.
The difference lies in how they achieve this: ISO 27001 provides an open framework within which you derive measures yourself based on your risk analysis. Grundschutz++ provides specific requirements that you can follow—with less room for interpretation.
➔ Not sure whether ISO 27001, Grundschutz++, or a combination of the two is the right approach for you? We’ll work with you to assess your customers, your requirements, and your current status—and determine specific next steps.
ISO 27001 provides an open framework: You largely derive your measures yourself based on a risk analysis. Grundschutz++ uses a catalog of specific requirements based on protection needs. This provides more guidance but leaves less room for interpretation.
The key factor is who will be reviewing the certification. If you primarily work with private clients and within supply chains, ISO 27001 is usually the right choice. If you have many public-sector clients, such as municipalities or government agencies, there are strong arguments in favor of Grundschutz++.
Yes. ISO 27001 certification can be obtained based on Grundschutz++. However, ISO 27001 certification can also be obtained independently.
A certificate demonstrates to the outside world that a defined security standard is being met and is often required by customers. More importantly, however, the measures must actually be implemented and continuously improved—IT security is a journey, not a one-time project.
More videos from the BSI-Grundschutz++ series:
Welcome to the next installment of our series on BSI Grundschutz++. Today, we’re comparing ISO 27001 and BSI Grundschutz++. This is important because it’s a key decision you’ll need to make if you want to get certified: either ISO 27001 on its own or ISO 27001 in conjunction with Grundschutz++. So, if you want to implement Grundschutz++, you do so in conjunction with ISO 27001. ISO 27001, on the other hand, can also be certified on its own. Many organizations do this, often due to customer requirements.
It’s important to understand: This is about IT security at your organization—about best practices that actually work. The certification is good; it demonstrates a certain standard to the outside world. Ultimately, however, the goal is for you to actually establish IT security or raise your security level. There’s always some residual risk. Nothing is completely secure unless you shut down all systems. So you can only keep improving—you’ll never reach 100 percent.
In principle, both pursue exactly this goal. They are management systems with slightly different approaches, but at their core, both are information security management systems, or ISMS for short. Procedures are defined, documented, and implemented. The most important aspect of this is the PDCA cycle—Plan, Do, Check, Act—that is, the continuous improvement process. The goal is to continually optimize and adapt: to new situations, new attack methods, new systems, and new employees.
Another key point: Management is responsible. Without support from senior management, it becomes very difficult. And it’s always about risk management—that’s the central element. You assess a wide variety of risks and act accordingly. Typically, you use a risk matrix with probability of occurrence on one axis and severity of impact on the other. You address the risks in the top-right quadrant first. In the new version, BSI Grundschutz++ can be certified in conjunction with ISO 27001.
What are the differences? BSI Grundschutz++ comes from the BSI, the German government agency, and is therefore a national standard. ISO 27001 is internationally recognized and is the global standard. Overall, ISO 27001 is more flexible: it provides a framework within which organizations can operate. Grundschutz++, on the other hand, provides a catalog of approximately 1,000 specific requirements—which have since been streamlined—that serve as a guide.
ISO 27001 focuses on the framework, particularly risk management. Within this framework, you have considerable freedom to design your approach and derive measures from the risk analysis. With Grundschutz++, the measures are derived based on the protection requirements. The risk management approach is more flexible under ISO 27001, whereas Grundschutz++ requires compliance with a few more criteria—but it’s all manageable.
ISO 27001 is, after all, a standard document that you have to purchase. It is not freely available, but it doesn’t cost an arm and a leg. Grundschutz++ is machine-readable and free of charge—both the requirements themselves and the measures you implement later. There is a great deal of flexibility in how ISO 27001 is implemented. ISO 27001 is recognized worldwide. In Germany, Grundschutz++ is particularly well-regarded among government agencies and public contracting authorities and is also used when an organization itself is a public institution.
From a bird’s-eye view: ISO 27001 offers more freedom, requires more effort on your part, and includes more components that you can design yourself. With Grundschutz++, more is prescribed. This helps because you can use it as a guide and follow along. However, you also have less leeway for interpretation—especially from a business perspective, that is, when it comes to deciding what to implement and what you consider appropriate.
What’s right for you? To find out, you should ask yourself a few questions. A rough estimate: With ISO 27001, you can very effectively demonstrate information security to private companies—and, of course, to yourself as well. If you have many public-sector clients—municipalities, government agencies, or other public contracting authorities—you should opt for BSI Grundschutz++. Theoretically, you could implement both. Above all, however, it’s important that you derive value from it yourself.
An even better question is: Who wants to see the proof? Customers and the supply chain: then ISO certification. Public sector: then the BSI methodology. And the most important point is your own business—your own business perspective. In the end, it doesn’t matter at all whether you’re certified or not. The most important thing is that you’ve implemented the measures and continue to do so on an ongoing basis.
Fundamentally, it’s always about the journey. It’s not just a certification—it’s an ongoing process. So what matters most to you isn’t the standard you end up with, but the path you take—step by step toward better IT security in your organization. If you have any questions, please feel free to reach out. We’ve included a link to schedule an appointment so you can speak with me directly, and together we can explore the best path forward for you. Thank you very much—and feel free to check out our other videos on BSI Grundschutz++.